USBCHA judging guidelines

 

Part 3: Scoring a National-Style Course

Outrun (20 Points)

The set-out crew should keep the stock settled at a location as near the “set-out post” as possible. The crew should attempt to keep the stock in that general area until the competing dog either affects the stock on his outrun by coming in tight or straight or the dog has completed his outrun and is ready to begin his lift. The harder the stock is to hold the quieter the set-out dog and handler must be.

Once the competing dog is sent on his outrun, there should be no whistling, shouting, waving of sticks or rash behavior by either the setout crew or their dogs. If it is necessary to recall the setout dog prior to the lift it should be without affecting the stock. Any of the aforementioned acts could result in not giving the competitor a fair chance to show the dog. Consideration should be given to the behavior of the stock. In scoring the outrun, lift and fetch, the judge must also consider the behavior of the set-out crew.

The dog must be positioned close to the handler/post. The handler will remain at the post from the commencement of the run and remain at the post until the first of the stock enters the shedding ring when a shed is required after the drive. The dog should run out, either right or left, in a cast that is neither too straight nor too wide, arriving behind his stock at a sufficient distance from them not to disturb them. Should the stock have moved, or be moving from the post, the correct end to the outrun should be when the dog is in a position to bring them straight to the first obstacle. A command by whistle should be considered the same as a spoken command. The dog should not stop and should not cut in. It is obviously more serious if a dog stops on his outrun than if he receives a re-direction without stopping and judges should mark accordingly.

Waiting for the stock to settle after being set out is permitted. However, the handler should be at the post and ready to send the dog as soon as possible. A good outrun should be the shape of one side of a pear with the blunt end of the pear at the stock’s end of the course (an outrun in the shape of a half circle is also be acceptable). The dog should finish the outrun far enough away from the stock so as not to disturb them. The outrun lasts from the time the dog is set in motion until the dog is in a position to lift the stock. The fence may interfere with the distance the dog can keep from the stock. Any penalties assessed will need to take this into account if it proves to be a factor.

Most judges do not judge the outrun until the lift is complete, as often the lift will indicate if the dog has run out to the correct place. If the dog walks straight toward the stock and they do not lift straight to the handler (or the first obstacle) then the dog may not have stopped in the correct place on his outrun.

Fault Description
Point Deduction
Dog set up more than four yards from the handler.
1–2 points
Dog set up more than 10 yards from the handler.
3–10 points
Dog sent before the handler reaches the post.
1–2 points
Handler slingshots the dog from behind him at the beginning of the outrun.
0–2 points
Dog runs too square at the beginning of the outrun.
1–4 points
Dog runs straight up the field (minimum 10 points).
10–19 points
Dog crosses the centerline of the field in front of the handler (minimum 10 points).
10–19 points
Dog runs too wide (minimum 1/2 point).
½–10 points
Dog runs to exhaust pen.
4–10 points
Dog recalled to post and re-sent.
19 points
Dog that is stopped or stops himself and is re-directed (minimum of 2 points).
2–4 points
Dog that is given a stop whistle and re-direct before stopping (minimum of 2 points).
2–4 points
Dog that is re-directed on the run (minimum 1/2 point).
½–3 points
Dog that is given whistle to keep going in the same direction.
½–2 points
Dog stops short (i.e. 11:00 or 1:00) or is stopped by the handler causing the stock to lift off-line.
1–2 points
Dog stops short as above and receives a re-direct.
1 point (plus points for stopping short)
Dog stops short between 3:00 and 1:00 or 9:00 and 11:00 causing the stock to lift off-line.
2–4 points
Dog stops short as above and receives a re-direct.
1–2 points (plus points for stopping short)
Dog over runs.
1–5 points
Dog off course.
5 points–DQ
Dog walks the last part of the outrun (i.e. 20 yards).
1–3 points
Dog buzzing stock on the outrun and causing them to lift off-line.
3–8 points
Dog is tight at the end of the outrun and disturbs the stock.
2–5 points
Dog runs to holding pen but comes to stock with 1-2 commands.
3–6 points
Dog runs to holding pen and requires many commands to come to the stock.
5–15 points
Dog stops to sniff the set-out dog.
1–3 points
Dog performing bodily functions on the course (This is the same point deduction no matter where on the course it might occur).
3–6 points
Dog spinning on the outrun.
2–4 points
Dog turning tail at any time.
2–5 points
Dog turns around on the outrun and starts back to the handler.
4–8 points
Dog turns around on the outrun and comes back some distance to the handler.
8–12 points

Lift (10 Points)

At the end of the outrun, whether the dog has come to a full stop or merely slowed down, his approach to the stock should be smooth, cautious and steady. The main feature of the “lift” is an ability to take control in a firm and quiet manner without disturbing the stock.

The dog should not rush in and thus startle the stock and should not lie back and require numerous commands before getting the stock to move.

Judges will deduct points for excessive commands, rash or rough work, slowness of approach, and any other faults. The stock should be lifted directly toward the first obstacle on the course (fetch gates or handlers’ post if there is no fetch gate).

In scoring faults, consideration should be given to whether there is heavy pressure back to the set-out pen, wool blindness, rough terrain, lifting hungry stock off feed, or interference from the set-out crew or their dogs.

Fault Description
Point Deduction
Dog doesn’t lift the stock straight toward the fetch gates.
0–3 points
Dog lifts stock back toward the let-out pen.
3–5 points
Dog rushes in and splits the stock.
4–9 points
Dog rushes the stock causing them to start too quickly.
2–8 points
Dog grips because it can’t shift the stock.
5 points–DQ
Dog lifts stock too slowly (without commands).
1–5 points
Dog requires excessive commands to lift the stock (more than one or two commands). Per commands after the first two.
½–1 point
Dog requires excessive commands to lift the stock (more than one or two commands). Per commands after the first two.
1–3 points

Fetch (20 Points)

Once the stock is on the move (lifted), they should be brought at a steady pace and in a straight line from the place of lifting through the gates and thereafter in a straight line to the handler. If the stock were spotted off line, they should not be brought back on line, but if the dog forces them off line by being tight on his outrun, they should be brought on line before beginning the fetch.

The dog should not hurry or over-flank the stock, especially if this means causing the stock to cross the course in a zigzag movement. Judges should consider all the relevant circumstances contributing to the missing of the gate and adjust their scoring accordingly.

The fetch ends when the stock has passed around behind the handler as close to the post as practical. If the stock initially misses the turn (goes on the wrong side of the post), the handler should make a reasonable attempt to get the stock around the post correctly before going on with the drive. If the handler is unable to get the sheep around the post in correct direction, the judge will deduct points for the missed obstacle as is appropriate and will continue to score the run.

The whole work should be in a steady smooth manner. Over flanking, unsteadiness, rushing, missing gates, deviation from line, and other faults will all be penalized, considering the disposition of the stock and the circumstances at hand. As with all parts of the course, failure to complete this phase of work before going on to the next phase will result in disqualification.

Fault Description
Point Deduction
Dog fetches the stock down the field too fast.
1–4 points
Dog chases stock down the field.
4–8 points
Dog brings the stock too slowly. (Time should sort out this problem).
0 points
Dog allows the stock to stop. Per stop.
0–1 point
Stock is off line all the way from the lift to the handler.
18–19 points
Off the required line all the way but hit the fetch gates.
10–16 points
Off line slightly then back on line.
1 point
10-30 yards off line and back on line quickly.
1–4 points
10-30 yards off line and allowed to remain off line for some distance.
2–8 points
Miss the fetch gates. Per head (minimum 1 point) (not to exceed 8 points for a missed panel).
1–2 points
Stock misses the fetch gates and then handler retries the gate. Deduction above for missing the gate plus.
3–5 points
Dog turning in circles or turning tail (this is the same deduction no matter where on the course It might occur). Per turn.
2–5 points
Dog allowing stock to spread out through lack of pressure.
1–3 points
Stock being allowed to graze through lack of pressure from the dog. Per stop.
1–2 points
Dog flanking excessively behind the stock instead of walking on. Per flank.
½–1 point
Handler commanding excessively.
1–4 points
Dog comes around in front of the stock (out of control). (Minimum deduction 3 points).
3–10 points
Dog circling stock. (Minimum deduction 3 points).
4–10 points
Dog turning stock back toward the set-out. (Minimum deduction 1 point).
1–8 points
Dog turning back for non-existent stock. (Minimum 2 points).
2–6 points
All stock going the wrong way around the post and continuing on with the drive.
8–10 points
All stock go the wrong way around the post and are brought back and taken around the post correctly.
2–6 points
All stock go part way around the post in the wrong direction and are brought back and taken around the post correctly.
1–5 points
If a legitimate effort has been made to turn the post but all the stock turn in front of the post.
6–12 points
One head goes around the post and the others don’t. Per head. (not to exceed 8 points).
2–3 points
All the stock go around the post but the turn is wide.
1–6 points
Dog leaves the stock and starts back to the handler.
1–10 points
Dog brings the stock back through the obstacle. Per head. (not to exceed 8 points).
1–2 points
If no attempt is made to turn the post.
DQ

Drive (30 Points)

The “Drive” usually takes place in a triangular pattern and can be run either from the left to right or right to left. The first leg of the triangle starts immediately as the stock pass behind the handler. The stock is required to go in a straight line to the first set of gates.

Having either made or missed the first gate, the stock should be turned immediately on to a direct line across the course to the second set of gates. When these gates are either made or missed, the stock should then be turned as neatly as possible on to a straight line to the shedding ring or pen, whichever is required. The dog should show obvious ability to drive steadily without excessive commands. Reasonable turns at the post and at both gates are expected. Good handling in difficult situations will be taken into consideration by the judge. As in the fetch, the gates are guides to the alignment of the stock. Throughout the drive, the stock should be kept moving gently. Bursts of speed and subsequent stopping are not desirable and should be penalized. If a gate is missed, the judge must consider all the relevant circumstances contributing to the miss and adjust deductions accordingly. The handler must remain at the post until the stock enters the shedding ring when a shed is required after the drive.

When the drive is followed by a pen, the handler may proceed to the pen after the stock have made or missed the final drive obstacle. However the drive is not completed until the stock are in what the judge deems to be the penning area. When the shed follows the drive, the handler will remain at the post until the first of the stock has entered the shedding area.

Any deviation from line, missing gates, rashness, circling stock or other faults will be penalized with due consideration to the disposition of the stock and all other circumstances. An honest attempt must be made for each drive obstacle. If the dog is unable to drive the stock to, through or past an obstacle, it may not proceed without loss of points and may be asked to retire.

Fault Description
Point Deduction
Dog flanking back around the handler to start the drive.
0–1 point
Handler moving more than 4 yards from the post.
1–3 points
Dog repeatedly looking back at the handler. Per look.
0–1 point
Dog turning right around and looking at the handler.
1–3 points
Dog turning to look at the handler and then continuing around to make a complete circle.
2–5 points
Dog moves the stock too fast.
1–4 points
Dog moves the stock too slowly. (Time should sort out this problem.)
0 points
Lack of pressure from the dog allows the stock to stop. Per stop.
0–1 points
Off line slightly then back on line.
1 point
10-30 yards off line and allowed to remain off line for some distance.
2–8 points
Dog turning in circles or turning tail. Per turn.
3–5 points
Dog allowing stock to spread out through lack of pressure.
1–3 points
Stock being allowed to graze through lack of pressure from the dog. Per stop.
1–2 points
Dog flanking excessively behind the stock instead of walking on.
1–8 points
Handler commanding excessively.
1–4 points
Dog comes around in front of the stock (out of control). (Minimum deduction 3 points).
3–10 points
Dog then turns the stock and drives them in the wrong direction on the course. Additional deduction.
2–8 points
Dog circling stock. (Minimum deduction 3 points).
3–10 points
Dog turning back to non-existent stock. (Minimum 2 points).
2–6 points
Stock miss gate. Per head (not to exceed 8 points for a missed panel).
1–2 points
Stock is brought back through the gate the wrong way. Per head (not to exceed 8 points for a missed panel).
1–2 points
Stock miss the gate and the handler retries the Gate. Deduction above for missing the gate plus additional points.
3–5 points
Wide turn at the gates.
1–4 points
Stock turns the wrong way after the obstacle.
1–5 points
Handler leaves the post before the stock is in the shedding area.
1–2 points
Handler enters the shedding ring before the first of the stock is in the ring.
2–4 points

Shed (10 Points)

There should be a clearly designated area for shedding. Although circumstances may dictate a smaller area or an unmarked ring, it is preferable that such an area be clearly marked and should measure 40 yards in diameter. When the shed is after the pen, the handler will proceed to the shedding ring, leaving the dog to bring the stock from the pen to the ring. The handler is forbidden to assist the dog in moving the stock. When the shed follows the drive, the handler will remain at the post until the first of the stock have entered the shedding area.

Having gotten the stock suitably positioned the dog should come in and take off the required stock and, once having taken them off, the dog must have them under control before the shed can be deemed satisfactory. Too much assistance on the part of the handler should be penalized as not allowing the dog to demonstrate his shedding ability to the judge. Nevertheless, the circumstances at hand should determine the appropriate point deduction. When the judge is requiring the last animals be shed, the judge should clearly explain to competitors how the judge is judging this work.

The dog must take full control of the shed stock to the judge’s satisfaction, otherwise the shed will not be deemed satisfactory and the shed should be penalized or the handler asked to reshed by the judge. Shedding must be done within the ring. Sheds performed outside the shedding area should not be accepted but must be repeated in the shedding area. Judges will apply suitable penalty in the case of ragged work, sheep moving out of the ring, splitting the stock incorrectly, when the shed is done by the handler, when opportunity to shed is missed etc. The test here being to ensure that the dog can shed off and control the required sheep.

On completion of the shedding, the dog will reunite all of the sheep, not necessarily within the ring but in a practical and workmanlike manner, and the handler must proceed to the pen, leaving the dog to bring the sheep to the pen.

Fault Description
Point Deduction
Stock leave the ring. Per head.
½–2 points
Dog chasing stock out of the ring. Per head.
1 point
Dog coming in between the handler and the stock before there is a shed.
2–5 points
Missed opportunity to shed.
1–3 points
Shed tried but not accomplished.
3–5 points
Handler provided too much assistance in making the shed and shed completed.
1–5 points
Handler provided too much assistance in holding, wearing or stopping the stock before or after the dog comes in for the shed.
1–5 points
Handler asking the dog repeatedly to come in because of hesitation or slowness on the dog’s part.
1–5 points
Dog flagging tail as he comes in to shed.
1–2 points
Dog turning on the wrong stock before turning to the correct stock.
2–5 points
Dog looking at the wrong stock on the way in on the shed.
0–2 points
Shed stock out of the ring before the dog is in control.
1–5 points
Unwanted stock is out of the ring before the dog has turned toward the shed stock.
2–5 points
Some or all of the stock are out of the ring when the dog is asked to shed. Dog must re-shed the stock in the ring.
3–5 points
Handler slow to ask the dog in on an opportunity.
1–3 points
Shed stock is allowed to rejoin the others before the shed is accepted by the judge. Must re-shed.
3–5 points

Pen (10 Points)

On completion of the shed, the handler must proceed to the pen, leaving the dog to bring the stock. The handler is forbidden to assist the dog in driving the stock to the pen. The handler will keep hold of the gate rope (6 ft. long) until the dog works the sheep into the pen and the gate is closed. The handler may assist the dog, but over assistance should be penalized, as should stock circling the pen or making breaks away from the pen, unsteadiness, rashness, slackness, or any other fault shown by the dog. Scoring for the pen begins when the stock is within 10 yards of the pen, or it is obvious that the penning has begun, in cases of the pen following the drive. When the pen follows the shed, the pen begins upon the judge’s acceptance of the shed. The pen is completed when the stock has been removed and the pen gate has been closed and fastened.

Fault Description
Point Deduction
Handler assists the dog in getting the stock from the shedding ring to the pen.
3–8 points
Stock breaks around the pen. Per head.
½–1 point
Stock gets out of the working area at the mouth of the pen.
1–3 points
Stock goes into the pen and then gets back out before the gate is closed.
2–5 points
Bumping stock with the gate.
1–3 points
Hitting stock hard with the gate. (Minimum 5 points)
5 points–DQ
Touching stock with crook or cane.
5 points–DQ
Hitting stock with crook or cane.
DQ
Stock goes into the pen with the dog way out of contact.
1–3 points
Dog circles the pen opposite direction to the stock to prevent the stock from going around the pen.
1–3 points
When the shed follows the pen and the handler must go into the pen to assist the dog in bringing out the sheep.
0–1 point
Dog giving ground as a result of being pressured by the stock.
1–5 points
Handler jumping, shouting, stamping while the dog lies back doing nothing.
1–4 points
Handler closes the pen gate before all the stock is penned.
DQ
Handler lets go of the rope accidentally.
0–1 point
Handler lets go of the rope to assist the dog
DQ
Stock become entangled in the rope and the handler doesn’t let go of the rope to release the stock in a reasonable manner.
5 points–DQ
Handler fails to close the gate once the stock is penned. Stock must be re-penned.
3–5 points
Handler slams the gate in an unsportsmanlike manner.
2–5 points
After the handler leaves the pen, having made a reasonable attempt to close and secure the gate, it re-opens.
0 points
A poor attempt is made to close the pen gate and it re-opens.
1–2 points
No attempt is made to close the pen gate after the pen is completed and the sheep are removed.
2–5 points
Pen gate is nearly closed to keep some of the stock in the pen while the others are being worked.
0–1 point

Single (10 Points)

There should be a clearly designated area for singling. Although circumstances may dictate a smaller area or an unmarked ring, it is preferable that such an area is clearly marked and should measure 40 yards in diameter. When the single is after the pen, the handler will proceed to the shedding ring, leaving the dog to bring the stock from the pen to the ring. Again, the handler is forbidden to assist the dog in moving the stock. When the single follows the drive, the handler will remain at the post until the first of the stock has entered the shedding area.

One head will be shed off within the shedding area and thereafter worn (inside or outside the ring) to the judge’s satisfaction. The cut off must be done within the ring, but the wearing may be outside or inside the ring, the test being the dog’s ability to hold or completely control a single. While shedding is a partnership between the handler and the dog, too much assistance on the part of the handler should be penalized as not allowing the dog to demonstrate his shedding ability to the judge. Handlers are forbidden to assist the dog in driving off or attempting to drive off the single any distance or by forcing the stock onto the dog. When the judge is requiring the last one be shed, the judge should clearly explain to competitors how the judge is judging this work.

If the judge feels that the dog has not been fairly tested owing to the disposition and action of the sheep he may order the handler to collect the stock again and shed off and wear any other animal. As with the shed the dog, not the handler, should come in and cut off the single. The greatest help the handler can give the dog is by getting out of the way and allowing the dog room to prove his ability to take off and wear a single. It is essential that the dog should be able to keep the single away from the remainder and the judge should not express satisfaction until the dog has been thoroughly tested. The judge when deciding whether the single has been effectively completed should consider the behavior of the stock.

Fault Description
Point Deduction
Dog crosses between the handler and the stock either in the ring or on the way from the pen to the ring.
2–5 points
Dog crosses between the sheep and the shedding area on the way from the pen to the shedding area.
1–2 points
Dog turns the sheep around the pen before bringing them to the shedding area.
2–4 points
Dog does not bring the stock directly into the shedding area.
2–4 points
Stock leaves the ring. Per head.
½–2 points
Dog chasing stock out of the ring.
1–5 points
Missed an opportunity to shed.
1–3 points
Shed tried but not accomplished.
3–5 points
Handler provided too much assistance in making the shed and shed completed.
1–5 points
Handler provided too much assistance in holding, wearing or stopping the stock before or after the dog comes in for the shed.
1–5 points
Handler asking the dog repeatedly to come in because of hesitation or slowness on the dog’s part.
1–5 points
Dog flagging tail as he comes in to shed.
1–2 points
Dog turning on the wrong animals before turning on to the correct stock.
2–5 points
Dog looking at the wrong group on the way in on the shed.
0–2 points
Shed animals out of the ring before the dog is in control.
1–5 points
Unwanted stock is out of the ring before the dog has turned toward the shed stock.
2–5 points
Some or all of the stock are out of the ring when the dog is asked to shed. Dog must re-shed the stock in the ring.
3–5 points
Handler is slow to ask a dog in on an opportunity.
1–3 points
Shed stock is allowed to rejoin the others before the shed is accepted by the judge. Must re-shed.
3–5 points